For over 20 years Benson has given individuals and businesses peace of mind by caring for their technology needs. Contact us today and let us make your technology work for you.

high-speed internet router in Syracuse Indiana

Address:

101 E. Main St., Suite B101 Syracuse, IN 46567

574-528-6118

Technology

Hidden Email Forwarding Rules: Could Someone Be Secretly Reading Your Business Emails?

Imagine discovering that someone has been secretly receiving copies of your company’s emails for the past three months.

Customer conversations.

Vendor invoices.

Financial information.

Employee communications.

Confidential business documents.

Everything appears normal. Your employees can still send and receive messages, and nobody has noticed anything unusual.

But behind the scenes, an unauthorized person may be collecting information without anyone realizing it.

How is that possible?

One method involves something surprisingly simple: email forwarding rules.

These rules are useful business tools, but in the wrong hands, they can become a serious cybersecurity threat.

Understanding how malicious forwarding rules work is an important step toward protecting your company’s email and sensitive information.

What Are Email Forwarding Rules?

Email forwarding rules are settings that automatically redirect or copy incoming messages to another email address.

Businesses use them for legitimate purposes every day.

For example:

  • Forwarding customer inquiries to a shared department mailbox
  • Redirecting messages during an employee’s vacation
  • Sending certain notifications to another team member
  • Organizing incoming messages
  • Managing communications for employees who have changed positions

When properly configured, these rules can improve efficiency and help employees manage their workloads.

Unfortunately, cybercriminals can abuse the same functionality.

How Hackers Use Email Forwarding Rules

Imagine an employee accidentally enters their Microsoft 365 password into a fraudulent website.

A criminal obtains the credentials and successfully accesses the employee’s email account.

Instead of immediately sending suspicious messages or changing the password, the attacker quietly creates a forwarding rule.

The rule might automatically send copies of incoming messages to an external email address controlled by the criminal.

The employee continues using their mailbox normally.

Customers receive replies.

Invoices arrive.

Everything appears to be working.

Meanwhile, the attacker may be collecting sensitive business information.

Some attackers also create rules that move certain messages into hidden or rarely checked folders.

For example, messages containing words such as “invoice,” “payment,” or “security alert” might be moved away from the inbox.

These changes can make suspicious activity harder for employees to notice.

Why Changing a Password May Not Be Enough

One of the most concerning aspects of malicious email forwarding rules is that they can sometimes remain active after an employee changes their password.

Suppose a business discovers that an email account was compromised.

The employee immediately changes their password.

Everyone assumes the problem is solved.

But if the attacker previously created an unauthorized forwarding rule, that rule may still exist.

Depending on the email system and its configuration, messages could continue being redirected even though the attacker can no longer sign in using the stolen password.

This is why responding to a compromised email account should involve more than a password reset.

Businesses should also review mailbox rules, forwarding settings, account permissions, active sessions, and authentication methods.

The Business Risks of Hidden Email Forwarding Rules

1. Exposure of Confidential Information

Business email often contains sensitive information.

An attacker receiving forwarded messages might gain access to:

  • Customer records
  • Financial reports
  • Employee information
  • Contracts
  • Internal business discussions
  • Vendor communications
  • Confidential attachments

Even if the attacker never changes a file, unauthorized access to this information can create serious business consequences.

2. Invoice and Payment Fraud

Criminals who monitor business email may learn when invoices are sent, which vendors are paid, and how financial transactions are handled.

They can use this information to create convincing fraudulent payment requests.

For example, an attacker might impersonate a vendor and request that future payments be sent to a different bank account.

Because the criminal has observed legitimate conversations, the fraudulent request may appear more believable.

3. Customer Impersonation

If an attacker understands how your company communicates with customers, they may attempt to impersonate your business.

They could send fraudulent messages requesting payments, login credentials, or confidential information.

This can damage customer trust and your company’s reputation.

4. Long-Term Information Collection

Some cyberattacks are designed to cause immediate disruption.

Others are designed to remain unnoticed.

Malicious forwarding rules can allow attackers to collect information over time without repeatedly signing into the compromised account.

The longer the activity continues, the more information may be exposed.

5. Hidden Security Notifications

Attackers may attempt to conceal evidence of account activity by creating rules that move, delete, or hide security-related messages.

An employee might never notice a warning because the message was automatically moved out of the inbox.

This makes regular account security reviews especially important.

Five Warning Signs Your Business Email May Be Compromised

Malicious forwarding rules don’t always create obvious symptoms, but certain warning signs deserve attention.

1. Missing emails

Employees report that expected messages aren’t appearing in their inboxes.

2. Unexpected mailbox rules

An employee discovers rules they don’t remember creating.

3. Unfamiliar forwarding addresses

Mailbox settings show that messages are being redirected to an unknown external email address.

4. Suspicious account activity

Security logs reveal unusual sign-ins, unexpected devices, or unfamiliar account changes.

5. Customers report strange messages

Customers receive unexpected payment requests or communications that appear to come from your business.

Any of these situations should be investigated promptly.

How to Protect Your Business From Malicious Email Forwarding

Fortunately, businesses can take practical steps to reduce the risk.

Enable Multi-Factor Authentication

Multi-factor authentication adds another layer of protection beyond a password.

Even if an attacker obtains an employee’s password, additional authentication requirements can make unauthorized access more difficult.

Phishing-resistant authentication methods provide stronger protection against certain credential theft attacks.

Restrict External Email Forwarding

Many business email platforms, including Microsoft 365, provide administrative controls for managing automatic external forwarding.

Organizations can restrict or block automatic forwarding to external addresses when it isn’t necessary for legitimate business operations.

These restrictions should be reviewed carefully to avoid interrupting approved workflows.

Review Mailbox Rules Regularly

Businesses should periodically review email forwarding settings and inbox rules.

Look for:

  • Unknown external email addresses
  • Rules created without authorization
  • Messages automatically moved to unusual folders
  • Rules that delete or hide certain emails
  • Unexpected changes to mailbox settings

A regular review can identify suspicious configurations before they create larger problems.

Monitor Account Activity

Security monitoring can help identify unusual sign-ins and suspicious account changes.

Businesses should review available alerts and investigate unexpected activity promptly.

Train Employees to Recognize Phishing

Many email compromises begin when an employee enters credentials into a fraudulent website.

Employee awareness remains an important defense.

Encourage staff to report suspicious login pages, unexpected authentication prompts, and unusual account behavior.

What Should You Do If You Discover an Unauthorized Forwarding Rule?

If your business discovers a suspicious forwarding rule, treat it as a potential security incident.

Simply deleting the rule may not be enough.

An appropriate response may include:

  1. Securing the affected account and resetting compromised credentials.
  2. Revoking suspicious active sessions.
  3. Reviewing multi-factor authentication methods and account recovery settings.
  4. Removing unauthorized forwarding rules and mailbox permissions.
  5. Investigating sign-in and audit logs.
  6. Determining whether sensitive information was exposed.
  7. Reviewing related accounts for additional suspicious activity.
  8. Evaluating whether customers, vendors, or other parties need to be notified.

The appropriate response depends on the circumstances.

Businesses should involve their IT provider promptly rather than assuming that removing one rule resolves the entire incident.

How Benson Communications Can Help

Benson Communications helps businesses maintain secure, dependable technology environments through proactive IT management and cybersecurity services.

Our team can assist with:

  • Microsoft 365 administration and security
  • Reviewing mailbox forwarding configurations
  • Managing user accounts and permissions
  • Implementing multi-factor authentication
  • Evaluating suspicious account activity
  • Managed antivirus and endpoint protection
  • Network security
  • Managed IT services
  • Backup and disaster recovery solutions

Our goal is to help businesses identify weaknesses before they lead to expensive disruptions.

Email security is particularly important because business communication often contains some of an organization’s most valuable information.

Protecting that information requires more than strong passwords.

It requires ongoing attention to account settings, permissions, and unusual activity.

Can Backups Protect Your Business Email?

Backups are an essential part of protecting business information, but it’s important to understand what they can and cannot do.

A backup won’t prevent someone from secretly receiving forwarded messages.

It also cannot undo information theft or reverse a fraudulent payment.

However, backups can play a critical role if an attacker deletes emails, damages files, or compromises other business systems.

For example, a criminal who gains unauthorized access to an account may attempt to delete important messages or files.

Depending on the systems involved and the backup coverage in place, properly maintained backups may allow the business to recover information that would otherwise be lost.

Businesses using Microsoft 365 should also understand the difference between built-in retention features and a dedicated backup strategy.

Retention policies and recycle bins serve useful purposes, but they don’t necessarily provide the same recovery capabilities as an independently managed backup solution.

That’s why backup coverage should be reviewed carefully.

Why Reliable Data Backups Are Essential for Every Business

Imagine discovering that an attacker has compromised your company’s email system.

Your IT provider secures the accounts and removes unauthorized forwarding rules.

But during the incident, important messages and business documents were deleted.

Your employees need those records to continue working.

Without a dependable backup, recovering that information may be difficult or impossible.

This is why Benson Communications places such a strong emphasis on protecting business data.

Our dependable data-backup solutions help businesses prepare for unexpected failures, accidental deletion, and other incidents that threaten critical information.

A comprehensive backup strategy should include:

  • Automated backups
  • Monitoring for backup failures
  • Appropriate off-site or isolated storage
  • Secure access controls
  • Suitable data retention periods
  • Regular recovery testing
  • Coverage for critical business systems and cloud information

Most importantly, businesses should verify that their backups can actually be restored.

A successful backup notification is reassuring, but a tested recovery provides much greater confidence.

Without Your Data, Everything Else Is Pointless

Businesses invest significant money in technology.

Computers.

Servers.

Firewalls.

Antivirus software.

Cloud services.

Email security.

Network monitoring.

All of these investments serve an important purpose.

But what are they ultimately protecting?

Your business information.

Customer records.

Accounting data.

Contracts.

Employee documents.

Emails.

Project files.

Operational procedures.

Years of accumulated business knowledge.

If that information disappears, replacing your computers won’t bring it back.

You could install the most advanced firewall available and still be unable to operate without your data.

That’s why every business needs a dependable, monitored, and regularly tested backup solution.

Without your data, everything else is pointless.

No matter how strong your cybersecurity becomes, make sure your critical information remains protected and recoverable.

Final Thoughts: Don’t Let Your Email Work Against You

Email forwarding rules are useful tools that can improve productivity.

But when attackers gain access to business accounts, those same features can become a way to secretly collect information and conceal suspicious activity.

Businesses should regularly review mailbox settings, restrict unnecessary external forwarding, implement strong authentication, and investigate unusual account behavior.

Benson Communications can help organizations strengthen their Microsoft 365 security, manage their technology environments, and protect the information that keeps their operations running.

And while you’re reviewing your email security, remember the most important question:

If your business email or critical files were deleted tomorrow, could you recover them?

If you’re unsure, it’s time to review your backup strategy.

Because protecting your business means more than preventing unauthorized access.

It means making sure your information is there when you need it most.

Author

Tech Bench